המביא גט ממדינת הים ואמר בפני נכתב אבל לא בפני נחתם. בפני נחתם אבל לא בפני נכתב. בפני נכתב כולו ובפני נחתם חציו בפני נכתב חציו ובפני נחתם כולו פסול. אחד אומר בפני נכתב ואחד אומר בפני נחתם פסול. שנים אומרים בפנינו נכתב ואחד אומר בפני נחתם פסול. ור' יהודה מכשיר. אחד אומר בפני נכתב ושנים אומרים בפנינו נחתם כשר.
If one brings a get from abroad and declares: “It was written in my presence” but not, “It was signed in my presence”; “It was signed in my presence” but not “It was written in my presence”; “All of it was written in my presence and in my presence but only one of the witnesses signed in my presence”; “Half was written in my presence but both witnesses signed in my presence”; [in all these cases] the get is invalid. If one says “It was written in my presence” and another says, “It was signed in my presence”, the get is invalid. If two say, “It was written in our presence” and another says, “It was signed in my presence”, it is invalid. Rabbi Judah declares it valid. If one says, “It was written in my presence” and two say, “It was signed in our presence”, it is valid.
Comments
Select a line on the left to view commentary.
Help support Theologa. Click to donate now!